A judge is set to decide whether to continue the murder case against Douglas Stewart Carter, who was released from jail after recent DNA testing failed to match him to the crime scene of a 1985 murder. At a Tuesday hearing, 4th District Court Judge Derek Pullan reached an agreement with Utah County prosecutors and defense lawyers regarding the necessity of further DNA testing.
DNA Testing and Legal Challenges
The upcoming ruling follows the release of the 71-year-old Carter from the Utah County jail on Sept. 28, 2026, after it was determined that crime scene DNA did not match him. While Carter has been released from custody, he still faces an aggravated murder charge related to the 1985 death of Eva Olesen, a Provo woman who was the aunt of the city's police chief at the time.
Carter's defense team has sought access to DNA extracts from the crime scene to allow an expert to conduct independent testing using genetic genealogy methods. This technique involves using public genealogy websites and profiles from at-home DNA testing kits to trace a DNA profile through a family tree, a method previously used by police to identify the Golden State Killer. The defense argues that identifying the true killer through this method would allow Carter to conclusively dispel suggestions of his involvement in the murder.
The DNA samples in question include blood found in an alleyway near the Olesen home and blood found on the knife authorities say was used in the killing. A previous defense expert testified that the killer likely cut himself on the knife while stabbing Olesen, leaving blood behind, an opinion that prosecutors have not publicly disputed.
Prosecutorial Opposition
Utah County prosecutors have expressed opposition to providing the samples, arguing that investigating the death of Eva Olesen is the responsibility of law enforcement rather than the defendant. Deputy Utah County Attorney Chris Ballard stated that providing samples to Carter could impair the constitutional rights of a future defendant who might be entitled to independent DNA testing if a new suspect is identified.
Ballard also noted that DNA evidence is not always definitive and can sometimes distract from the investigation. He cited a recent Utah County case where a male DNA profile found at a crime scene actually belonged to a technician who had a cold at the scene, rather than a suspect.
Background of the Case
The legal proceedings for Carter have been marked by significant shifts in the prosecution's stance. After decades spent on Utah's death row, prosecutors dropped their pursuit of the death penalty after state crime lab workers determined the crime scene DNA did not match Carter. Carter's conviction was previously overturned and the Utah Supreme Court ordered a new trial following allegations of police misconduct regarding evidence and witnesses.
Next Steps in Court
While the defense seeks to use advanced genealogy to clear his name, the Olesen family has maintained that they are not convinced Carter was not involved in her death. In addition to the DNA testing debate, Judge Pullan stated he intends to rule on whether a confession previously made by Carter is admissible in court.