The College Football Playoff selection committee faces scrutiny regarding how it will rank Brigham Young University as the postseason approaches. Despite a signature victory against Notre Dame, the Cougars currently sit at No. 10 in the rankings, while Oregon and Ohio State continue to climb.
Selection committee chairman Hunter Yurachek noted that BYU's win over Notre Dame keeps the 8-2 Cougars one spot ahead of 9-1 Wake Forest. However, Yurachek explained that the rise of Big Ten teams is driven by strength of schedule, noting Oregon has a strength of schedule of nine and Ohio State has a strength of schedule of 16. The committee has indicated it sees separation between the top 12 teams and No. 13 Oregon, though it is not bound by week-by-week ranking precedents.
BYU's path to improving its standing is limited, as its strength of schedule is projected to slip following upcoming games against Kansas and Cincinnati. The Cougars have been 29-6 since the start of 2024. Observers note that the team's defense has been consistent and the return of LJ Martin to the backfield from injury is expected to boost the offense.
The current situation mirrors past seasons where the committee's decisions left the Cougars out of the playoffs. In 2024, the committee omitted a 10-2 BYU from the bubble conversation despite losses only occurring against Texas Tech, while teams with 9-3 records like Alabama, Mississippi, and South Carolina were considered. In a previous season, BYU was ranked on the 11-seed line for three weeks before losing to Texas Tech in the Big 12 championship, resulting in a trip to the Pop-Tarts Bowl while Miami entered the bracket.
As the season continues, the Cougars face the possibility of being left out of the bracket again if they finish 10-2 and fail to secure the Big 12's automatic bid, especially if Oregon or Ohio State reach 9-3.