The BYU defense received near-perfect marks following the Cougars' 24-10 win over Iowa State on Friday, October 9, 2026, according to a report published October 11 by Brandon Gurney. The victory at LaVell Edwards Stadium in Provo, Utah, was highlighted by a standout performance from quarterback Bear Bachmeier and a stout defensive showing.
Bear Bachmeier earned an A grade for his performance, completing 22 of 30 passes for 329 yards and two touchdowns. In addition to his passing, Bachmeier recorded 109 rushing yards on nine carries. The offensive line received a B- grade, as the unit provided Bachmeier with ample time on most throws, though the group struggled with run-blocking during short-yardage situations.
The defensive units were highly rated, with the defensive line receiving an A for an effective pass rush and stout run defense. Linebackers earned an A- grade, led by Cade Uluave and Jake Clifton, who recorded six and five tackles respectively. The safeties also received an A- grade, while the cornerbacks earned an A, with Therrian Alexander noted for impactful coverage and tackling in the flat.
The offensive attack saw significant contributions from the tight ends, specifically Walker Lyons, who recorded five receptions for 61 yards. Roger Saleapaga also contributed a 63-yard reception to set up a touchdown. However, the running back group received a C- grade, as Journee Tonga, Preston Rex, and DeVaughn Eka struggled to remain effective in the absence of LJ Martin.
The coaching staff received a B grade. Defensive coordinator Kelly Poppinga had previously stated his focus was for the defenders to start better and provide consistent play throughout 60 minutes, a goal that was met during the win. Offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick was praised for involving tight ends more in the passing game, though the group faced challenges with redzone execution and short-yardage plays.
The special teams unit received a C- grade due to subpar punt fielding by Tiger Bachmeier, who muffed two punt returns during the game.
