The Utah Civic Compact is calling on Governor Spencer Cox to halt the use of vendor-owned license plate readers on state highways, alleging the Utah Department of Transportation (UDOT) lacks the legal authority to license private vendors. The watchdog group argues that UDOT's current permitting process for companies like Flock Safety bypasses state statutes intended to hold law enforcement agencies accountable for surveillance technology.
Legal Authority and Statutory Conflicts
The request for a pause comes as the Utah Civic Compact challenges the legality of UDOT's agreement with Flock Safety, a vendor that provides automated license plate reader (ALPR) technology. According to a report by the Compact on November 16, 2026, UDOT granted Flock Safety a statewide license on July 9, 2024, through Agreement No. 258065. This agreement allows the company to conduct operations across the state, regardless of which law enforcement agency has contracted for its services.
Statutory Requirements for Agencies
The dispute centers on a conflict between UDOT administrative rules and existing state law. Under S.B. 250, which was passed in 2023 and sponsored by Senator Daniel McCay, law enforcement agencies must obtain a special use permit from UDOT before installing a plate reader aimed at a state highway. Utah Code 72-1-212 defines this permit as one issued specifically to a law enforcement agency to install an automatic license plate reader on a state highway, and it mandates that the installation, maintenance, data collection, and removal are the responsibility of the agency that obtains the permit.
Vendor Operations vs. Agency Responsibility
The Utah Civic Compact argues that UDOT's rule, R920-4-16, which was adopted in November 2023, attempts to create a vendor license that the legislature did not authorize. Jarom Gillins, the Director of Policy for the Utah Civic Compact and a member of its Board of Directors, stated that no statute authorizes UDOT to license a vendor. Gillins, a U.S. Army veteran and former independent candidate for the U.S. House in Utah's 2nd Congressional District in 2026, argued that because Flock Safety leases its cameras and manages their installation and maintenance, it is performing duties that the statute assigns to the permit holder.
Surveillance Data and Oversight
The Compact's investigation was prompted by previous findings regarding surveillance data usage. In August, the group released Weber County records showing that 10 Flock cameras authorized by the county had been searched more than 5 million times since February 2022, with nearly all searches conducted by agencies located outside of Utah. This revelation previously led Governor Cox to state he was "deeply troubled" and questioned whether existing legislation was being followed.
Proposed Regulatory Action
The Utah Civic Compact is requesting that Governor Cox use his authority to direct UDOT to pause the use of vendor-owned cameras in the state highway right-of-way until the Legislature passes new regulations. The group noted that UDOT maintains the power to remove installations that do not comply with the transportation code under Utah Code 72-7-104, making a pause a smaller step than the law already permits. They emphasized that a pause would not revoke any existing police agency permits.
Demands for Legislative Review
The group has also called on the General Oversight Committee to review UDOT's rule R920-4-16 before the 2027 General Session. They have requested that the committee ask UDOT which statute authorizes the vendor provisions and ask for copies of every license agreement UDOT has signed under the rule. The Compact argues that if vendors are to be part of plate reader systems, the Legislature should set the terms in statute, ensuring the agency remains responsible for every camera.
Privacy and Accountability Concerns
The Utah Civic Compact maintains that the current system fails to align with recommendations from the Utah Privacy Commission's task force. The task force has recommended that agencies should own and control the data collected by their systems, while vendors should only process it on the agency's behalf. The Compact contends that current practices allow vendors to hold statewide licenses that bypass the accountability intended by Utah's existing privacy laws.