BYU football suffered a surprising 39-31 double overtime loss to UCF at the Acrisure Bounce House in Orland, Florida, according to a report published October 25. BYU football beat reporter Brandon Gurney assigned low grades across the board to the Cougars' position groups and coaching staff following the October 24 game.
Quarterback Bear Bachmeier received a C grade after recording 257 passing yards on 50 percent completion and 37 rushing yards on 15 carries. While Bachmeier contributed two touchdown passes, his performance included one interception. The offensive line earned a C+ grade, struggling to support the run game and providing average protection for Bachmeier, especially after replacement Trevin Ostler left the game with an injury following the absence of starter Kyle Sfarcioc.
Receiver Kyler Kasper was noted as the lone effective offensive weapon, finishing with six receptions for 129 yards and a touchdown. Tight end Walker Lyons contributed to the offense but dropped a pass in the second overtime period that could have extended the game. The running back unit received a C- grade, as Sione Moa recorded 36 yards on 13 carries and Preston Rex gained 42 yards on five carries.
The defensive performance was marked by significant struggles, receiving low grades for the defensive line (D+), linebackers (D), and safeties/cornerbacks (C+). The defensive line failed to pressure UCF quarterback Keyone Jenkins or force him out of his comfort zone. The linebacker unit struggled with missed tackles, including a notable failed tackle by senior Isaiah Glasker during a 3rd-and-17 situation. The defensive backs faced pressure due to a lack of pass rush, resulting in several chunk plays and no forced turnovers.
The coaching staff received a C- grade for the loss. While the special teams unit earned a B, including a 47-yard field goal by Matthais Dunn and effective punting by Fuller Shurtz, the offensive play-calling was criticized for being hyper-conservative. Offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick opted for three consecutive runs during a late-game situation instead of an aggressive touchdown attempt. Additionally, the defense appeared unprepared for UCF's offensive system during the 60 minutes of regulation and two overtime periods.
