BYU football beat reporter Brandon Gurney issued performance grades for the Cougars following a 27-20 win over Arizona State at LaVell Edwards Stadium in Provo, Utah, in a report published November 1, 2026. The assessment noted dramatic highs and lows across the roster during the victory.
The quarterback position received a B- grade for Bear Bachmeier, who displayed strong arm strength, including a touchdown pass to Kyler Kasper, but also threw a critical interception late in the first half. The running back group was graded a D, as the unavailability of LJ Martin and an injury to Preston Rex limited the ground game. While Sione Moa scored two touchdown runs, he managed only 20 yards on eight carries. The offensive line earned a B- after providing good pass protection despite losing Trevin Ostler to injury, while Kyle Sfarcioc returned to the lineup.
Defensive units saw mixed results, with the cornerbacks earning an A for Therrian Alexander and Jayven Williams. Williams recorded six solo tackles, while Alexander limited opponent Reed Harris to one reception for four yards. The safeties received a B, led by Faletau Satuala's nine tackles and impactful play from Raider Damuni. Conversely, the linebackers were graded a C- due to missed tackles, specifically a missed tackle by Cade Uluave on Arizona State quarterback Jake Fette. The defensive line received a C+ as Arizona State freshman Cardae Mack ran for 123 yards on 26 carries.
Special teams earned a B, highlighted by a late 45-yard field goal from Matthias Dunn. The coaching staff received a B-, with the report noting that defensive scheming was effective, though tackling issues persisted. On offense, Bachmeier reportedly showed frustration with conservative play-calling from offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick during the game.
Coach Kalani Sitake will focus on improving tackling technique during the next week's preparation time for the upcoming game against Utah.
