Brigham Young University freshman Carter Smith earned $2 million for himself and $1 million for charity after successfully making a 33-yard field goal during ESPN's College GameDay on Saturday, Oct. 17, 2026, in Provo. Smith, an Iowa native, secured the largest payout in the history of the pregame show's weekly kicking contest while wearing a Spider-Man costume.
A High-Stakes Challenge
The high-stakes moment occurred on the BYU campus prior to the football team's matchup against Notre Dame. While the standard challenge hosted by ESPN personality and former NFL kicker Pat McAfee typically involves a $1 million prize, the stakes were increased after Utah Jazz owner Ryan Smith and his business partner, Ryan Sweeney, agreed to add $1 million each to the total pot.
Smith, a 21-year-old from Honey Creek, Iowa, was not originally the first person selected to participate. According to the Daily Herald, a student who was deemed ineligible because they did not have their identification on them was originally chosen, resulting in Smith being selected in their place.
Adjusting for Success
The experience was marked by unexpected circumstances, including Smith's attire and footwear. Smith and his friend, Andrew, decided to attend the event wearing Spider-Man costumes of various sizes. Smith noted that if he had not been wearing the costume, the moment might not have felt as significant.
Adding to the difficulty, Smith had to borrow running shoes from a member of the crowd because he was wearing Birkenstocks. During his first attempt at the 33-yard kick, Smith missed wide to the right. He later explained that he felt he had a second chance and attempted to adjust his approach by aiming high and to the left, a strategy that resulted in the successful kick.
A Whirlwind of Fame
The successful kick triggered an immediate surge of attention for the student. Following the event, Smith reported receiving a whirlwind of messages on social media, including requests for tuition assistance and messages from former acquaintances.
Smith also described the pressure of the legal requirements following the win. A representative from the production handed him a document to notarize and return via email within seven days, noting that failure to comply would result in receiving no money. Smith confirmed he has already completed the necessary paperwork.
Reflections on the Win
Smith, who is currently in his first semester at BYU and intends to become a dentist, reflected on the emotional weight of the moment. He described feeling relief that he did not fail on national television and noted feeling overwhelmed, stating he felt "out of my own skin." He also expressed gratitude for the opportunity and the potential impact of the windfall.
Before the kick, Smith was standing in line to enter "The Pit," the designated area for the raffle, when an individual offered him $400 for his spot in line. Smith decided not to accept the offer, a decision he believes contributed to his ultimate success.
Future Financial Plans
Despite the sudden wealth, Smith's life has largely returned to a normal routine. By Monday, the student was walking around campus unbothered, noting that the initial intensity of being recognized by strangers has subsided.
Regarding his financial future, Smith stated he has no immediate financial needs and plans to be responsible with the money. He intends to conduct research before making long-term decisions, such as investing in stocks, a 401k, or rental properties. He cited the Book of Mormon, advising himself to "be wise" with the funds.
Looking Ahead
Smith, who played soccer at Underwood High School in Iowa but has no prior football experience, has now transitioned from a student to a millionaire. He remains focused on his studies at BYU while managing the implications of his recent national television appearance.
Record Payout
The $3 million total payout marks a significant milestone for the College GameDay segment, fueled by the additional contributions from local Utah business leaders Ryan Smith and Ryan Sweeney.
